"Masse" and Group Attitudes

Submitted by Ben Bache on

Many mental-health professionals have voiced the opinion that Donald Trump exhibits symptoms of narcissistic personality disorder (NPD). A Change.org petition posted on January 26, 2017 by Baltimore psychologist John Gartner urging Trump’s cabinet to invoke the 25th Amendment to remove him from office received 60,000 signatures by October 2017. Gartner told the Baltimore Sun that he believed Trump was a “malignant narcissist.” In a 2015 Vanity Fair article several mental-health professionals had agreed that Trump appeared to present symptoms of NPD, but Harvard’s Howard Gardner identified what for him was a more serious problem. “For me,” he told Vanity Fair, “the compelling question is the psychological state of his supporters.”

Otto Kernberg, Professor Emeritus of Psychiatry at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City wrote an article for Psychoanalytic Quarterly in 2020 titled “Malignant Narcissism and Large Group Regression.” (Kernberg 2020)

The term malignant narcissism was first used by psychoanalyst Erich Fromm in 1964, calling it a “severe mental sickness” that was the “quintessence of evil.” Malignant narcissism is now regarded as a combination of traits that can appear in narcissistic personality disorder and antisocial personality disorder.

Narcissistic personality disorder is characterized by grandiosity, need for admiration, and lack of empathy.

Darkness for Light: Christofascism and the Right-Wing Appropriation of Religion

Submitted by Ben Bache on

The word “evangelical” is derived from the Greek euangelion, which in classical Greek meant “the reward for bringing good news.” In New Testament times the sense of the word was transferred to mean the good tidings themselves. The 2nd century Church Fathers  began referring to the authors of the Gospels – Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John – as Evangelists, “bringers of the “good news” of Jesus Christ.

Martin Luther used “evangelical” to describe his theology when he separated from the Catholic church in the 16th century in part over his belief that sins are forgiven based on faith alone, and not “works” – acts performed with the expectation of a reward.

“Evangelical” became associated with the first “Great Awakening,” in eighteenth century America where under the influence of Puritan Jonathan Edwards, among others, it represented the “good news” of salvation through Christ, emphasizing the need for a personal conversion experience. It was the latter that can be identified with the phrase “born again.” As the emphasis on conversion extended to converting outsiders evangelicalism became associated with revivalism. In its focus on spiritual rebirth and individual devotion American evangelicalism drew on the doctrine of pietism, which rejects political control of spiritual affairs, in the words of James Emery White, rejecting the “compulsory and cultural” in favor of the “voluntary and personal.”

The National Association of Evangelicals (NAE) was founded in 1942. By its own account the timing did not seem particularly auspicious for the creation of an ecclesiastical organization. The US was just emerging from the Great Depression, and had suffered through two world wars, which, along with advances in organic chemistry, astronomy and anthropology, called into question the existence, power, and goodness of a deity.

The Thirty Years Culture War

Submitted by Ben Bache on

The whirlwind of events of the last several weeks have displaced more familiar political analyses in much popular media. An apparent attempt at assassinating former president Donald Trump on the eve of the Republican convention, Joe Biden’s withdrawal from the 2024 presidential race, and Vice President Harris replacing him at the head of the ticket would each have been unusual, striking events individually, but taken together sent commentators and analysts in search of precedents.

Yet amid or in spite of the unusual events, some things quickly reverted to normal. Despite a professed “toning down” of violent language from Republicans, Trump and newly anointed elegiac hillbilly VP candidate JD Vance “doubled down” on violent language, especially that directed at migrants and immigrants. And with that, some things were back to “normal,” at least as far as Republican candidate sound bites were concerned.

What had in the runup to the events of mid-July seemed newly bold right-wing rhetoric pervading Republican party communications has been treated by some commentators as something new. Certainly the January 6, 2021 riot represented a new level of violence in the nation’s capital. To find a precedent for the placement of bombs one must look back to the 1983 bombing of the Senate side of the Capitol building, ostensibly to protest US involvement in Grenada. In its conception and coordination, however, January 6 most closely resembled the so-called Brooks Brothers riot in Miami in 2000, largely coordinated by Bush campaign official Brad Blakeman, but including future Trump partisan Roger Stone and others who would become members of the George W. Bush administration. Like the January 6 riot, the goal of the Brooks Brothers riot was to stop a vote-counting process, resorting to violence if necessary.

In his recent book When the Clock Broke, writer John Ganz locates the origins of multiple aspects of our current political and cultural environment in events, people, and actions from the 90s. For example: the mythologizing of criminal figures as popular outlaws he associates with legendary mafioso John Gotti; the trend toward political movements that purport to oppose political movements he associates with the quixotic campaigns of Ross Perot; the rightward shift of the Republican party he associates with one-time grand wizard of the Ku Klux Klan David Duke, and serial presidential candidate Pat Buchanan.

Trump's Bogus Denial of Project 2025: Turning Point?

Submitted by Ben Bache on

During the recent BET awards TV broadcast, host Taraji P, Henson used the platform to issue repeated warnings that a win by Republican Donald Trump in the November presidential election would, in Philadelphia Inquirer’s Will Bunch’s words, “undermine our fundamental rights.” Bunch, who has been one of the few op-ed writers at a major news outlet to focus on Trump and his lies in the aftermath of the recent presidential debate, sees Henson’s use of her platform to warn of the GOP’s plans to drastically change the relationship between government and citizens as a potential turning point in the presidential campaign. While the details of Project 2025 are apparently not widely known, the 900+ page document is publicly available, and touted by right-wing pundits – including principal architect, Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts – on conservative media.

Voting rights website Democracy Docket describes Project 2025 as “a collection of policy transition proposals” that would enable Trump, if elected, to “vastly remake the federal government most effectively to carry out an extremist far-right agenda.”

The Party Formerly Known As Republican - Trump and Beyond

Submitted by Ben Bache on

Trump and Beyond

The 2016 Republican primary featured 17 candidates. Pop data analysis website fivethirtyeight.com has an analysis of each failed candidate’s arc titled “How the Republican Field Dwindled From 17 To Donald Trump.” The reasons are varied, from Ted Cruz being too extreme and disliked, to Marco Rubio lacking a base, to Republicans liking Ben Carson, but not enough to vote for him.

The Party Formerly Known As Republican - "W" to the Tea Party

Submitted by Ben Bache on

"W" to the Tea Party

“Poppy” Bush's son, George W. Bush (aka “W”), worked with campaign manager Lee Atwater during Bush senior’s presidential campaign. In W’s 1994 campaign for Governor of Texas his master of disinformation was political operative and self-described “nerd,” Karl Rove. Rove remained a key advisor to Bush until 2007.

The Party Formerly Known As Republican - Ford to Gingrich

Submitted by Ben Bache on

Ford to Gingrich

Gerald Ford had been appointed Vice President under the terms of the 25th Amendment in December 1973 following Spiro Agnew’s resignation. When Ford assumed the presidency in August 1974 following Nixon’s resignation, and chose Nelson Rockefeller as his Vice President some saw it as a resurgence of the moderate wing of the Republican party.

The Party Formerly Known As Republican - Hoover to Nixon

Submitted by Ben Bache on

Hoover to Nixon

In 1928 the Democratic candidate for president was Alfred E. Smith, a Roman Catholic and opponent of prohibition. Republican Herbert Hoover defeated him as Republicans carried the former Confederate states for the first time since Reconstruction. Republicans resisted government intervention in the economy in response to the stock market crash of 1929 and the subsequent Great Depression.

The Party Formerly Known As Republican - Origins

Submitted by Ben Bache on

Origins

In 1820 the Missouri Compromise was enacted by the US Congress as an effort to preserve the balance of political power between slaveholder and free states. Missouri was admitted as a slave state; Maine was admitted as a free state. Perhaps more significantly, slavery was also prohibited in the former Louisiana territory north of latitude 36° 30’, which was part of the boundary between Missouri and Arkansas.

The Party Formerly Known As Republican

Submitted by Ben Bache on

Introduction

“The Republican Party is an authoritarian outlier,” wrote Vox’s Zach Beauchamp in September 2020. Beauchamp was writing in the context of the rush to confirm Federalist Society darling Amy Coney Barrett as a Supreme Court justice following the death of liberal icon Ruth Bader Ginsburg, despite several Republicans having refused to consider a nominee to the court “in an election year” during the Obama administration. Citing experts on comparative politics including Harvard’s Steven Zilitsky, who with Daniel Ziblatt authored New York Times bestselling How Democracies Die, Beauchamp writes that the GOP should no longer be considered in the same category with traditional conservative political parties such as Canada’s Conservative Party (CPC) or Germany’s Christian Democratic Party (CDU), but rather as an extremist party like Orban’s Fidesz in Hungary, or Erdogan’s AKP in Turkey, which “actively worked to dismantle democracy in their own countries.”

In this series of articles we’ll trace the evolution of today’s white nationalist authoritarian Republican party from its origins in opposition to the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854, through the party’s nomination of Barry Goldwater in 1964 and his “Southern Strategy” appealing to racial fears of southern white voters, to Newt Gingrich’s “Contract with America,” to the Tea Party, and Donald Trump. In conclusion we’ll look at predictions by Zilitsky and Ziblatt and others, and their prognoses for the Republican Party and American democracy.